• Employment agencies
  • Custom systems

Off-the-shelf ATS or a custom system for an employment agency — which to choose?

Krzysztof Frąszczak and Piotr Frąszczak ·

In short

An off-the-shelf ATS is usually enough for an agency that mainly recruits: it posts job ads, collects CVs and takes candidates through to being hired by the client. A custom system pays off for a temporary staffing agency, where most of the office work starts after recruitment — contracts, time tracking, settlements with many clients and residence and work-permit legalisation for foreign workers. Often the best option is a middle way: keep the ATS and add the missing modules and integrations.

ATS vs. a system for an employment agency — what’s the difference

An ATS (Applicant Tracking System) is a system for running recruitment: job ads, a candidate database, CVs, process stages, recruiter notes. For an HR department or a recruitment firm, that is often all you need.

A temporary staffing agency has a different problem. Recruitment is only the beginning — then come contracts, assignments to clients, working hours across many sites, settlements with workers and invoicing clients, and for workers from abroad also residence and work-permit legalisation. If the system doesn’t handle this, the office does — in spreadsheets, emails and on paper.

So the question “off-the-shelf ATS or custom system” really comes down to another one: where does your agency lose the most time — before the candidate is hired, or after?

When an off-the-shelf ATS is enough

  • The agency mainly recruits and passes candidates on to clients rather than employing them itself.
  • The process is standard: job ad, CV, interview, offer.
  • The number of clients and settlement rules is small and can be managed with simple tools.
  • You need a system quickly and the budget doesn’t allow for a project.
  • You accept that you adapt to the product, not the product to you.

In that situation a custom system would be overkill. It’s better to buy a ready-made tool and possibly improve one step, such as reading CVs.

When a custom system pays off

  • You employ temporary workers and are responsible for their contracts, hours and pay.
  • You serve many clients and many sites, each with different rates and settlement rules.
  • You employ foreign workers and handle residence and work-permit legalisation.
  • You have several branches, each working in its own way.
  • The same data is re-keyed between the ATS, a timesheet spreadsheet, the payroll system and invoices.
  • Candidates drop out before starting because they have to come to the office to sign the contract.
  • Growing the agency means hiring more people to handle paperwork.

The more of these points apply, the more likely it is that the cost of a custom system will pay for itself in office time.

Comparison

Off-the-shelf ATS Custom system
Start Fast — an account and configuration Requires analysis, design and development
Cost Subscription, usually based on the number of users or features Higher up-front cost, then maintenance and development
Scope Mainly recruitment The agency’s whole process: recruitment, contracts, working time, settlements
Fit The agency adapts to the product The system mirrors the agency’s process
Many branches and clients Depends on the product Designed in from the start
Integrations Whatever the vendor has provided For your job boards, payroll, accounting and clients
Development On the vendor’s roadmap According to the agency’s needs

The middle way: ATS + custom modules

You don’t have to choose “all or nothing”. Often the most sensible approach is to keep the ATS your team is used to and add what is missing:

  • reading CVs in any format — PDF, Word, scan, photo — and saving a ready profile in the ATS (AI CV parsing),
  • the first conversation with the candidate, following the agency’s script (AI Recruiter),
  • remote contract signing on a phone,
  • time tracking and settlements that the ATS leaves out.

If it later turns out that the ATS is holding the agency back, the modules stay and become part of a larger system.

Checklist: 10 questions before you decide

  1. How much time does the office spend on work after the candidate is hired (contracts, hours, settlements)?
  2. How many times is the same data entered manually in different tools?
  3. How many clients and sites do you have with different rates and settlement rules?
  4. Do you employ foreign workers, and how do you handle residence and work-permit legalisation today?
  5. Do candidates drop out at the contract-signing stage?
  6. Do you have several branches, and do they work to one standard?
  7. Which job boards, payroll system and accounting software must the system connect to?
  8. Did the off-the-shelf product show your process on your data in the demo, not a sample one?
  9. What happens to your data if you want to change provider?
  10. Can you start with one module and extend the system in stages?

If the answers to questions 1–7 show that most of the work happens after hiring, an ATS alone won’t solve it.

How Coblit does it

We build custom systems and AI agents for temporary staffing agencies and recruitment firms — from reading CVs and pre-screening candidates to remote contract signing, time tracking and client settlements. We have experience with agencies in Poland and France. Details: systems and AI for employment agencies.

  • R2T — for a large employment agency in Île-de-France and other major French cities, we built one system for all branches: recruitment, CRM, projects, document workflow, payments and settlements, with integrations with recruitment portals. Result: more than 30% less manual work, a paperless model and easier opening of new agencies.
  • KADO — a mobile app for a hostess agency in which contracts are signed 100% remotely. Fewer drop-outs before starting and assignments that begin sooner.
  • AI recruitment chatbot — a system that takes the candidate from the first message (website, forms, WhatsApp), through reading the CV, ID card, passport and work permits, to signing the contract in SignSafe. It integrates with ATS, CRM and HR systems — an example of the middle way. More about it: recruitment chatbot.

We process candidate data in line with GDPR, on servers in the EU, and the hiring decision is always made by a person. We usually start with the module that takes up the most time and extend the system in stages. If you want to estimate a budget, see also how much a custom system costs.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Which system should a temporary staffing agency choose?

One that covers not only recruitment, but also contracts, working time and client settlements. If an off-the-shelf ATS stops at hiring the candidate, a temporary staffing agency usually needs a custom system or additional modules.

Can an off-the-shelf ATS handle time tracking and client settlements?

Not always. Many ATS products focus on the recruitment process, so before you buy, check in a demo whether the product can calculate hours and settlements using your real data and your clients' rules.

Can we keep our current ATS and add only the missing modules?

Yes. Coblit integrates its solutions with ATS, CRM and HR systems — this is how, for example, our AI recruitment chatbot works, taking the candidate from the first message to a signed contract.

Where should we start when building a system for an employment agency?

With the module that takes up most of the office's time, such as reading CVs or signing contracts. At Coblit we extend the system in stages, so you don't have to replace everything at once.

Who builds custom systems for employment agencies?

Coblit. We built a complete system for the French employment agency R2T — with recruitment, CRM, document workflow and settlements — which cut manual work by more than 30%, and a remote contract-signing app for the hostess agency KADO.

Let’s talk

Have a similar question in your company?

In 30 minutes we’ll go through your processes and tell you straight what is worth doing, how much it costs and where to start.

Book a consultation
Book a 30-min call